
Kotaku revealed today that Peter Molyneux sent a note along with the review copy of Fable 2 that Vanity Fair received. In it he asks that Vanity Fair to “[. . .] please, please, please, please, please find somebody who doesn’t play games, watch them play it and see how their world turns out, because I think it’s only when you see those differences that the unique experiences comes through.”
I think there’s some good ideas here. As gamers, when we read reviews, we’re only getting the opinions of people that have played dozens if not hundreds of games before. While every reviewer (at least in theory) tries to be objective, to play the game with fresh eyes, without a doubt their experiences with other games will seep into their reviews, possibly coloring their opinions. This is especially true of games that are the next installment in a series, as reviewers’ previous experience with the series can (negatively or positively) color their reviews. (Although this doesn’t happen all the time: compare PC Gamer’s review score for Crysis: Warhead to it’s review score for Crysis (98%), for example).
In the end, I think Molyneux’s idea has merit. But it does also come off as a kind of plea to give the game to a non-gamer so it’ll get a higher score. I’m hoping his intentions were pure. Who knows? If everyone added a non-gamer’s opnion to their reviews, we might just see a more balanced, less biased set of opnions than we might get otherwise. We could hear opinions from everyone (or closer), and less the select few.
And who doesn’t want that?
Today’s photo is from flickr user *clarity*. The original photo can be found here and is used under Creative Commons licensing.


